Date:
October 22, 2004 Copyright:
Internet News.com By Susan Kuchinskas
In 1995, Jack Ma, now the CEO of Alibaba, founded
China Pages, probably China's first Internet company. After
a stint as head of the China International Electronic Commerce
Center's Infoshare division, he launched the Alibaba business-to-business
trading site in 1999.
Today, Alibaba operates three online marketplaces:
Alibaba International, an English-language site focused on
international trade, with one million registered users from
more than 200 countries and territories; Alibaba China, which
enables domestic business-to-business trade, mostly among
small and medium-sized enterprises, and counts 3.8 million
among its registered users; and Taobao, a consumer-to-consumer
(C2C) trading site with 2.2 million registered users.
Ma was happy with his B2B niche until eBay bought
a third of EachNet, a Chinese C2C presence, in June 2002.
In May 2003, Ma launched his own consumer trading site, Taobao,
hoping to distract eBay from the lucrative Chinese small business
market. In July 2004, Ma invested another $42 million in the
operation in anticipation of a wave of investment and advertising
by eBay.
The outspoken Ma seems to relish his image as
an underdog. He talked with internetnews.com about the opportunities
in China, what foreign businesses do wrong and how Jack goes
about killing the giant.
Q: Now that eBay has moved into China with its
acquisition of EachNet, how do you plan to compete?
Every time when we read about China, they say
that the C2C game is over. They say eBay has taken the lead,
and Yahoo is second. But that's not the truth. The C2C game
is not over in China. When we launched Taobao, everybody said
you're ridiculous, fighting something that is so huge. I strongly
believe we have a chance. Last year, before we launched, Chinese
Internet usage had grown to over 82 million. EachNet still
has less than 5 million users.
We have the experience of building an electronic
marketplace with Alibaba China. EBay may be very famous in
the U.S.A., but in China, if you ask 100 people if they've
heard about eBay, I believe that less than 10 percent have
heard of them. But if you ask 100 people if they've heard
about Alibaba, 90 percent know about us. Our name is growing.
Q: But are those business owners or consumers?
In China, there are so many small businesses
that people don't make a clear distinction between business
and consumer. Small business and consumer behavior are very
similar. One person makes the decisions for the whole organization.
Q: Still, wasn't it risky to launch the consumer
trading site?
At the beginning, when we launched our C2C,
we thought eBay was very powerful. We launched Taobao not
to make money, but because in the U.S., eBay gets a lot of
its revenue from small businesses. We knew that someday, eBay
would come in our direction.
Q: You may have awareness now, but can't eBay
outspend you?
EachNet spent more than us last year. We prepared
the Taobao site last May and launched July 10. Last June,
eBay injected a lot of money in EachNet. When we came out,
they paid no attention to us. They thought we were a peanut.
In September, they spent millions of dollars and signed exclusive
rights with all the portal sites -- because they had more
money than we did. After one year of their advertising and
exclusivity, we had more traffic than they did. We still have
more traffic.
EBay is now very nervous. They committed the
same mistakes that most multinational companies make when
they come to China.
First, they are very successful in the U.S and
Europe, so they believe their model will work in China. But
the environment is different. You have to start from scratch.
When they go there, I suggest they should send
people with leadership and entrepreneurship and start from
nothing. Fight for the market, and make the customer happy.
Second, they want to replace the local management.
I think the EachNet team has been there for five years, and
they understand the Chinese market very well. But they suddenly
replaced the general manager with a German guy who does not
speak Chinese and who doesn't understand the market; they
brought in a CTO from the U.S. -- and the whole thing crashed.
Next, they spend too much money. They think,
'I have more money than local companies, and with money, I
can destroy you.' The way Taobao fights with eBay, they have
100 bullets, I have 10. So we make them waste bullets shooting
at a wall. They're wasting money like water.
They also pay too much attention to the government
relationship. China has changed from the 80s when you had
to have a close alliance with the government. Now, 90 percent
of the companies that claimed they had a strong relationship
with the government are bankrupt. Government employees move
on, and then you're screwed.
Another thing eBay did wrong was to too quickly
globalize their technology platform. When eBay announced that
eBay China had moved to the eBay platform, there was a big
celebration. I call it the kiss of death. Read the forums;
they're all complaining. In China today, it's not the technology
that's important, it's how you meet the customers and understand
them
Q: Aren't there significant barriers to e-commerce
in China, including unreliable shipping and a lack of an electronic
payment infrastructure?
I don't expect China will have as efficient
an economic environment as in the U.S. in three years. You
always have to work within in the current environment. Shipping
may not be so sophisticated as in the U.S.A., but it works.
We have our own ways on how to pay. People wire the money.
They use escrow accounts, wire the money to Taobao, and we
pay the seller.
Q: You're building a mobile commerce platform
with Intel. What's the status of that?
There are over 300 million mobile phones in
China. Intel sees the 4 million small-business Alibaba members
and wants to target them. We have only 350 engineers for 4
million members, and we don't think we can meet their needs.
So we're looking to partners to help us develop some new platforms,
applications and technologies. Intel came to us and asked
us, 'Why not do a wireless platform?' It will let anybody
who wants to buy and sell thru Alibaba communicate from a
mobile phone to our Web site. A lot of our customers are rich
people, and they want to buy a mobile phone that has business
use. The project is still in its beginnings, but the phone
is on the market.
Q: How is next year shaping up?
EBay is very strong, but the first battle was
just finished after one year. The result is, in the first
round, Taobao didn't win, but eBay lost. We'll see in the
next year what happens.
|